I am reading one of the most controversial political philosophy books of the 20th century named The Concept of the Political by Carl Schmitt. Schmitt was German jurist, who wrote The Concept of the Political in 1932. Its main thesis is that the essence of politics involves the friend/enemy distinction. The “enemy” is the other of a collective that threatens a groups very existential condition. Schmitt is criticizing a liberal conception of politics in which neutrality is proposed while ignoring the reality that conflict is innate to politics. This distinction arises from the fact that people are diverse and pluralistic and this diversity of beliefs often come into conflict with one another. I am about a third of the way through the book right now, but it seems to be an anti-utopian book about the harsh reality of the political world.
Sadly I think there is a tremendous amount of truth in The Concept of the Political by Schmitt. Recently the podcast host Jennifer Welch had to apologize for laughing at a joke during her podcast that thought it was funny to dig up Charlie Kirk and shoot him again. I also had a family member once say the worst thing about the Trump assassination attempt was that “it didn't work” sadly. I am also reminded of in 2016 when Trump said to “knock the crap” out of protestors. I think these are all examples of treating political out-groups as Schmittian enemies. Schmitt is likely onto something that politics deeply involves the friend/enemy dichotomy.
Humans like to think in binaries, especially of the in and out-group variety. We join teams politically and blindly and dogmatically follow our political in-group regardless of how unethical our own in-group acts. Our in-group is our “friends,” as Schmitt would point out. Schmitt doesn’t think you can ever remove the possibility of violence from occurring in politics. Freud notes in Civilization and it’s Discontents that “man is a wolf to man,” and given the fact that it personally doesn’t seem to be that the basic goodness of humanity comes out in politics often, the world often seems like a dystopian mess. Some of my mental health problems with depression could be coloring my view on the possibility of cooperation in politics but the antagonism that people have towards those they disagree with seems to run deep.
I do not agree with Schmitt though that the essence of politics is the friend/enemy distinction. I do think it is possible for people to not out-group people they disagree with politically. I think that people have to put in an intentional effort to not turn people they disagree with into enemies and out-group them. This requires effort to see the humanity of other people even when you disagree with them. I have meet a few people who try to do this, although admittedly it is not many. One of my favorite journalists is Glenn Greenwald and it’s as if he has no in-group in a politically partisan fashion. He will criticize anyone regardless of whether they are on the left or right. It’s as if he has no friend/enemy distinction.
While I think the vast majority of people do think of politics in a friend/enemy distinction, I don’t think we have to as human beings. I believe it is possible to not think overtly an in and out-group binary, although most people don’t seem to be willing to put in the work to not think like that. Some of the answer I believe is honestly just to be well read and understand the distinction between the left and right in politics. One of the books I can’t recommend enough is A Conflict of Visions by Thomas Sowell which has a great explanation for why people disagree so much in politics. Also reading Isaiah Berlin is a great person to understand political philosophy through. Overcoming the friend/enemy distinction is desperately needed in politics and while I do think most people think in this binary, I also think it is possible to not think this way and doesn’t have to be the essence of politics. My hope is that someday we overcome the friend/enemy distinction and the in and out-group binaries of politics and move towards something more humane. I don’t know if this is actually possible but I hope it is. Thank you.

